App icon Would you rather?
App Store Would you rather?
App icon Would you rather? Would you rather? Get

Missing the magic of Hogwarts amidst the humdrum of muggle life? We fellow wizards and witches understand the struggle of living in a mundane world. But fear not, for we’ve brewed up something special just for you!

Introducing the enchanting Harry Potter edition of “Would You Rather”! Pour yourself a frothy Butterbeer, gather your fellow housemates, and dive deep into a realm of spellbinding, and occasionally dark, dilemmas. From daring duels to perplexing potions, see where your magical instincts lead you with these uniquely themed Harry Potter “Would You Rather” questions. Let the wizarding fun commence! 🪄

Best Friend Quiz
How well do your friends know you?
Get Started

How to Play Harry Potter “Would You Rather”

Our Harry Potter edition of Would You Rather follows the same rules as any other version of this game. Would You Rather is an easy social game where the players have to choose between two different options. Sometimes those options are completely different, but sometimes they are quite similar. It depends on the questions. But the important thing is: Everyone has to choose one of them!

For example: Harry says: Would you rather like to fight with a giant or a dementor?

And then the other player or the other players have to choose between fighting a giant or a dementor.

👉 If you want to know more about the game and get more than 500+ “Would You Rather“ Questions, check out this article: Would You Rather!

Tip: The Harry Potter DVD box set is a must-have for any fan of the magical world of Hogwarts! This comprehensive set includes all eight movies, plus bonus features that will take you even deeper into the wizarding world:

Available on

Play “Would You Rather“ online

Are you looking for an easy way to play Would You Rather online? Check out our free app, which you can download on Apple App Store and Google Play Store.

App icon Would you rather?
Would you rather? Rated 4.9 stars out of five stars

If you don’t want to download anything, you can always play our web app:

Play Would you rather? online

Harry Potter “Would You Rather“ Questions

Are you ready for the best Harry Potter-themed “Would You Rather“ questions? The following questions are about our beloved magical characters, creatures, jobs, food, and more!

1. Would you rather drink pumpkin juice or Butterbeer?

In my opinion, both options sound delicious!

2. Would you rather eat a Chocolate Frog or a Flobberworm?

I bet that the first one is pretty tasty, but maybe one crazy friend of yours prefers the Flobberworm? Yuck…

3. Would you rather own a phoenix or a hippogriff?

Both are pretty majestic!

4. Would you rather save Fred Weasley or Lily Potter?

This question is so evil. I love both! And you?

5. Would you rather be a Healer or a Broom Maker?

Imagine one of these would be your job… Amazing!

6. Would you rather spend a week with the Dursleys or in Azkaban?

Oh my god… Both options are just SO terrible. What do you think about it?

7. Would you rather jinx Padma Patil or Cho Chang?

If you were Ginny, you would definitely choose Cho Chang. But you aren’t Ginny! So who do you choose?

8. Would you rather kiss Harry Potter or Ron Weasley?

And yes, of course, with tongue!

9. Would you rather be friends with Fang or Nagini?

Hm… Both friendships would be useful!

10. Would you rather join Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw?

Are you more loyal or clever?

11. Would You Rather fight with a ghost or a ghoul?

Fighting with a ghost is likely to be quite difficult as it cannot be touched. But you certainly can’t get injured during the fight!

12. Would you rather be an Animagus or a Metamorphmagus?

Would you rather be an insect-like Rita Skeeter and eavesdrop on everyone? Or a quick-change artist like Tonks?

13. Would you rather use an invisibility cloak or a time-turner?

Phh, that’s really tough. Both would be great!

14. Would you rather kiss Mr. Weasley or Mr. Malfoy?

I’d better leave this question uncommented.

15. Would you rather fight with a goblin or a dragon?

If you choose the dragon, which dragon exactly? Chinese Fireball, Hungarian Horntail, Romanian Longhorn, or a completely different one?

16. Would you rather be in Gryffindor or Slytherin?

Are you Team Harry or Team Draco?

17. Would you rather be the Hogwarts Express driver or the Librarian at the library of Hogwarts?

I think both jobs are very exciting.

18. Would you rather be trapped in the Chamber of Secrets or the Forbidden Forest?

I mean, at least there are no more basilisks in the Chamber of Secrets, right?

19. Would you rather visit the Malfoy Manor or the Burrow?

Yes, we are now ignoring that the Burrow burned down. Maybe the Weasleys just conjured it up again? (Or maybe it was Hermione. That sounds more likely!)

20. Would you rather work at the Three Broomsticks Inn or at Honeydukes?

Free butterbeer for everyone!

21. Would you rather be a werewolf or a ghost?

Hm… If you’re a werewolf and aren’t fortunate enough to have a potion expert in your family, you are likely to hurt innocent people. But if you’re a ghost, you’re already dead.

22. Would you rather kiss Hermione Granger or Ginny Weasley?

One thing is certain: Harry and Ron will not be happy about it at all!

23. Would you rather join Dumbledore’s Army or the Death Eaters?

This decision really shouldn’t be a tough one. If yes, what the hell is wrong with you?

24. Would you rather save Lavender Brown or Dobby?

Ah, sorry, Lavender. But my answer is Dobby!

25. Would you rather visit a Deathday Party or a Quidditch match?

Don’t you know what a Deathday Party is? Read the books!!

26. Would you rather drink tea made by Hagrid or the blood of a unicorn?

Oh, Hagrid’s tea!

27. Would you rather fight with a giant or a dementor?

I think both situations are not exactly comfortable.

28. Would you rather kiss Fred or George Weasley?

And now the question of all questions: Can you even tell the twins apart?

29. Would you rather punch Mr. Malfoy or Bellatrix Lestrange?

Uh, like Hermione in the third part. By the way, did you know Emma Watson actually hit Tom Felton in this scene? He said afterward that it hurt like hell!

30. Would you rather join the Death Eaters or Slytherin?

Are you evil or worse than evil? Tricky question!

31. Would you rather read the daily prophet or a book written by Gilderoy Lockhart?

Oh, the books Gilderoy Lockhart wrote! I would actually love to read them!

32. Would you rather kiss Draco Malfoy or Cedric Diggory?

Are you more into bad boys or pale vampires?

33. Would you rather be an Auror or a famous Quidditch player?

These are probably the best jobs in the wizarding world. Both are exciting and dangerous, and you would never get bored!

34. Would you rather own an owl or a cat?

Hmm, is both an option? (Spoiler alert: No!)

35. Would you rather attend the Halloween or Christmas feast at Hogwarts?

The food would be amazing!

36. Would you rather take Care of Magical Creatures or Defence Against the Dark Arts?

Probably the question also depends on the teachers.

37. Would you rather save Professor Dumbledore or Remus Lupin?

Oh, this question breaks my heart.

38. Would you rather drink Madame Maxime’s Single Malt Whisky or pumpkin juice?

Remember: the whiskey is really only for her horses.

39. Would you rather fight with a troll or a three-headed dog?

I’m scared.

40. Would you rather be friends with Hagrid or Professor Sprout?

Who wouldn’t want to be friends with Hagrid? (Okay, maybe someone who is afraid of aggressive, wild, supernatural animals. I get that.)

41. Would you rather save Lord Voldemort or the serpent of Slytherin?

I’m curious.

42. Would you rather visit Durmstrang or Beauxbatons?

Unfortunately, too little is said about these two schools in the works of J. K. Rowling.

43. Would you rather kiss Dudley Dursley or Vincent Crabbe?

Ahm. Okay. No comment from my side.

44. Would you rather punch Pansy Parkinson or Argus Filch?

No matter what you choose: I understand.

45. Would you rather save Cedric Diggory or Sirius Black?

Sorry, Mr. Diggory, but I think we all would choose Sirius! For Harry’s sake!

46. Would you rather visit Diagon Alley or Hogsmeade?

Hmm… Choose wisely! Maybe it will come true!

47. Would you rather work at the St Mungo’s Hospital or the Ministry of Magic?

You certainly have a lot of responsibility in both professions.

48. Would you rather attend the Yule Ball or the Quidditch World Cup?

And yes, the ball takes place at Hogwarts!

49. Would you rather become an Animagus or learn the ability to Apparate?

Ph, that’s a tough one!

50. Would you rather pull a prank on Mrs. Weasley or Professor Dumbledore?

Hopefully, they don’t curse you!

51. Would you rather punch Draco Malfoy or Lord Voldemort?

Of course, you would be invisible. So they wouldn’t know it’s you!

52. Would you rather kiss Professor Dumbledore or Hagrid?

Hmm… I’m outta here.

53. Would you rather own Hedwig or Crookshanks?

Yes, you have to make a decision here too!

54. Would you rather be a student of Hogwarts or Durmstrang?

Ah, the decision of your magical schooling! What will it be?

55. Would you rather go to a Quidditch match or attend a wizarding duel?

The excitement is real! But choose carefully. It could be very dangerous!

That’s all for our Harry Potter-inspired “Would You Rather“ questions. If you’re looking for more party games, check out our complete list of party games for any occasion!

🥳 Party 🤓 Quizzes 🕹 Games ✍️ Name Generators 👋 Conversation Starters 💭 Quotes 🍿 Videos 🎓 Trivia 📱 Apps 🛒 Shop

Party & Drinking Games

Looking for some fun party games to liven up your next get-together? Check out our collection of 100+ party games for all ages!