App icon Would you rather?
Would you rather? App Store
App icon Would you rather? Would you rather? Get

Boo! Halloween is just around the corner, and we have a fun, spooky surprise for you! As the eerie shadows of Halloween creep up on us, we present a frightfully fun twist to the epic game “Would you rather”.

It’s all about Halloween choices that will make you scratch your head and maybe even shiver a little. So, get ready, folks. It’s time to dive into a world of spooky questions and silly scares.

Best Friend Quiz
How well do your friends know you?
Get Started

What is Halloween Would You Rather? 🤓

In case you haven’t heard of Would You Rather yet, here’s a short explanation: Would You Rather is a question game where you have to choose between two given options.

In the Halloween version of Would You Rather, the questions get really dark and scary. Therefore some of these questions are rather hard to answer.

Now that you know how to play, let’s get into the questions!

Halloween Would You Rather Questions For Adults 🎃

This list contains a variety of Halloween questions. From gross to funny - this list has it all.

1. Would you rather spend 1 year in Solitary Confinement or get physically tortured 3 hours a day for 1 year but live in a prison cell with other inmates?

Mental torture or physical torture, what is worse?

2. Would you rather have a friendly but scary-looking monster under your bed for the rest of your life or have nightmares every day for the rest of your life?

How would you feel if you had an ugly monster living under your bed?

3. Would you rather drink a cup of blood or eat one bite of human flesh?

I’ve warned you that some questions are gross.

N e w !
App icon Drawly
Drawly | Multiplayer Drawing & Guessing Game
Rated 4.8 stars out of five stars

4. Would you rather be attacked by 20 bats or 20 tarantulas?

What animals would do more harm, and how would you defend yourself?

Which Pokémon are you based on your personality? Quiz
There are so many different Pokémon out there. But which one are you?
Start Quiz

5. Would you rather be possessed by the devil or live in a haunted house for the rest of your life?

Both will drive you insane.

6. Would you rather only watch romantic comedies for the rest of your life or only watch horror movies for the rest of your life?

What genre do you like better?

7. Would you rather be eaten by maggots from the inside out or be eaten by piranhas from the outside in?

Does it even matter? However, I like to be in control. That’s why I would choose to be eaten from the outside in.

8. Would you rather be killed by a vampire or get turned into a vampire?

Would you like to live forever?

9. Would you rather get kidnapped by a psychopath or get abducted by aliens?

I’ve never met aliens. So there is a chance that they are actually friendly creatures. Psychopaths, on the other hand, are most likely not nice.

📖 Suggested read: Halloween Charades | Spooky & Funny Ideas for All Ages

10. Would you rather turn into a zombie or a vampire?

If we assume that zombies and vampires look like in the movies, then vampires are definitely the hotter ones.

11. Would you rather live as a ghost on earth after you die or just stay dead?

What fun things would you do if you were a ghost?

12. Would you rather go to a Halloween Party or stay at home and watch horror movies with your friends?

It probably depends a lot on whether you’re more introverted or extroverted.

13. Would you rather die from a shark attack or die from a zombie attack?

Which death is less painful, and which is quicker?

14. Would you rather save your mom and let 100 innocent people die or save 100 innocent people and let your mom die?

Saving 100 strangers or saving your mom? For me, this question is tough and easy at the same time. What does your heart and what does your head say?

15. Would you rather have sex with Frank N. Furter from “The Rocky Horror Picture Show” or with Jared Leto as the Joker in “Suicide Squad”?

I have to admit that I have a little crush on Frank N. Furter. And to all the people who haven’t watched “The Rocky Horror Picture Show” yet, put it on your watch list now!

🤓 Suggested read: 🎃 Top 5 Halloween Games for Adults

16. If there was a zombie apocalypse, Would you rather choose a hair spray and a lighter or a rolling pin as your weapon?

Both weapons are not ideal. However, how would you use each of them as a weapon, and which of them would be more useful to defend yourself?

17. Would you rather have a creepy clown as your constant companion but nobody else can see them, or have a mischievous poltergeist as a roommate who loves to play pranks on you?

In my imagination, having a poltergeist as a roommate doesn’t seem too bad.

Horror Would You Rather Questions 💀

Do you love Horror movies? Then these Would You Rather questions are just right for you.

1. Would you rather have dinner with Hannibal Lecter or with Patrick Bateman?

If Patrick Bateman wasn’t a psychopath, I would definitely have “dinner” with him. 😏

2. Would you rather have visual hallucinations of “The Ring” girl or Freddy Krueger from “A Nightmare on Elm Street”?

Who creeps you out more?

3. Would you rather get kidnapped by Jigsaw from the movie “Saw” or kill yourself?

Would you play Jigsaw’s game? Who knows, maybe you’re lucky and make it out alive.

Would You Rather Questions for Adults
Suggested read: Would You Rather Questions for Adults

4. Would you rather spend a night at Bates Motel or spend a night in room 1408?

Both are terrible places to be. What place is “safer”?

5. Would you rather say “Bloody Marry” three times in front of the mirror or read the book from “The Babadook”?

When I was 11 years old, my best friend and I challenged each other to shout “Bloody Marry” three times in front of the mirror in the dark. We’re alive, obviously. But after that, we were pretty paranoid for a while.

6. Would you rather forever be chased by Pennywise or forever run away from the creature from “It Follows”?

I hate clowns. However, being followed by a shape-shifting creature sounds terrible too.

7. Would you rather have the old lady Mrs. Sylvia Ganush from the movie “Drag Me to Hell” as your grandmother or have Rosemary’s baby from the movie “Rosemary’s Baby”?

Possessed grandma or possessed baby?

8. Would you rather move into the house from the movie “Paranormal Activity” or the house from the movie “Insidious”?

Both homes are cursed. So which house is the lesser evil?

9. Would you rather get stabbed by the killer from the movie “Scream” or get eaten alive by the shark from the movie “Jaws”?

How would you like to die?

📖 Suggested read: 🎃 Top 5 Halloween Party Games for Teens

10. Would you rather fight zombies like Alice from the movie “Resident Evil” or participate in “The Purge”?

If you were like Alice, at least you wouldn’t have to kill people. However, where are the chances higher to get killed?

11. Would you rather be trapped in a room with Annabelle or with Chuckie?

Both dolls creep me out. Which of the two dolls is scarier to you?

12. Would you rather be stuck on “Shutter Island” or be stuck in the mental institution “Briarcliff” from the TV-Show “American Horror Story” (Season: 2 “Asylum”)?

Both places will drive you insane.

13. Would you rather play the lead role in the “Sharknado” movies or play the lead role in the movie “Troll 2”?

Have you seen these movies? If you like trash movies, you will love both of them.

14. Would you rather go camping in the woods from the “Blair Witch Project” or in the forest from “Evil Dead”?

I am not too fond of camping in general, let alone in a cursed forest.

15. Would you rather watch your mum be tortured by Jigsaw or cut off your own arm?

Would you sacrifice your arm to save your mom from being tortured?

16. Would you rather have a new “Saw” movie or a new “Scream” movie?

I think there are already enough movies from “Saw” and “Scream”. What do you think?

🤓 Suggested read: 30 Halloween Truth Questions & Dares For Your Next Party

17. Would you rather be pursued by a relentless, supernatural killer like Michael Myers from “Halloween” or be trapped in a haunted house with vengeful spirits like the ones in “The Conjuring”?

Do you prefer the thrill of evading a relentless slasher or the spine-chilling encounters with vengeful apparitions?

Scary Would You Rather Questions 👻

Let’s continue with more creepy and morbid Would You Rather Halloween questions. This question list is also suitable for people who know nothing about horror movies.

1. Would you rather wake up in a glass coffin that slowly fills up with water or wake up in a locked room that is on fire?

Do you think there is even a chance to escape? If so, how would you try to do it?

2. Would you rather be the first or the last who turns into a zombie in a zombie apocalypse?

What’s worse, seeing all your loved ones turn into zombies or being the first one that turns into a zombie?

3. Would you rather be possessed by a demon or find out that all your family members are possessed by demons?

If your family members were possessed by demons all along, you are lucky to be still alive.

4. Would you rather accidentally bite off the tip of your tongue or accidentally rip off your small finger?

Ouch. What would be more painful?

5. Would you rather find out that your adopted parents are actually aliens that eat corpses, but beyond that, they are really nice “people”, or find out that your partner has been cheating on you with your best friend for one year?

I mean, the people are already dead. So is it really that bad that your parents are scavengers? Unlike your partner and best friend, your alien parents are at least nice.

The Best Halloween Party Ideas for 2023
Suggested read: The Best Halloween Party Ideas for 2023

6. Would you rather live with a curse that gives you bad luck for one year and get 1 Million dollars afterward, or live curse-free and don’t get any money?

Having bad luck can mean different things. Would you take the risk for a million dollars?

7. Would you rather drown or burn to death?

Have you heard of Quang Duc, a Vietnamese monk who set himself on fire as an act of protest? You should check out his story. It’s extremely sad but also very powerful.

8. Would you rather have a child who has violent fantasies and shows signs of psychopathy but is otherwise physically healthy or have a mentally healthy child with a severe physical disability?

Do you think there’s a cure or at least a successful treatment for psychopathy?

9. Would you rather have a long and painful death in your 80s or a quick and sudden one in your 40s?

When I was a child/teenager, I always thought that 40 years-olds are super old. Now in my mid-twenties, I’ve realized that 40 years is relatively young.

10. Would you rather pull out all your fingernails with pliers or pull out your front teeth with pliers?

You definitely would need a lot of strength to pull out your front teeth.

11. Would you rather know when you die or how you die?

Most of the people I know said they wouldn’t want to know when or how they will die. Do you think the same, or do you think there also would be good things about knowing when or how you will die?

👉 Suggested read: Top 6 Halloween Board Games For All Ages

12. Would you rather have no legs or no fingers?

What’s more inconvenient? What challenges would you face in your daily life?

13. Would you rather save your pet or save your worst enemy?

Save someone you love or someone you hate? Do you think that one human life is worth more than one animal life, even if you hate this human?

14. Would you rather every time you have sex, it takes one day off your life, or every time you masturbate, it takes one day off your life?

What do you do more often? And how frequently would you masturbate or have sex knowing that you lose one day of life every time you do it?

15. Would you rather get kidnapped by Jack from the movie “The House That Jack Built” or by Hannibal Lecter?

I watched the movie “The House That Jack Built” just yesterday. It was definitely one of the most disturbing films I’ve ever seen. However, I highly recommend watching this movie if you are a fan of horror movies.

16. Would you rather see the girl from “The Ring” every time you look up into the mirror or feel something touch your foot every time you sleep?

I would never take a look in the mirror ever again. Someone would have to pluck my eyebrows for me. 😂

17. Would you rather spend a night alone in an abandoned psychiatric hospital or spend a night alone in a cemetery known for its haunted history?

Which eerie location would send shivers down your spine?

🤓 Suggested read: 30 Fun Trivia Questions To Challenge Your Brain

BONUS: Halloween Would You Rather Questions For Kids 🍬

Do you have kids? Then these questions are perfect for you. We’ve gathered the best Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids. However, even as an adult, they are still fun to answer.

1. Would you rather have a pumpkin for a head or have skeleton hands?

If you had a pumpkin head, you’d definitely stand out from the crowd.

2. Would you rather eat all of your Halloween candy right away or only eat one candy every day for a year?

Eat a lot of candy at once (and probably have a stomach ache afterward), or eat a little candy every day?

3. Would you rather be able to fly on a broomstick or have a magic wand?

What would you do with your magic wand?

4. Would you rather have Halloween just once a year or all year round?

How much of a Halloween fan are you? And what costumes would you wear if you could dress up every day?

5. Would you rather want to be a superhero or a villain for Halloween?

Do you want to be the good or the bad guy?

6. Would you rather go trick or treating with your friends or watch a scary movie at home with your friends?

I find both options to be great fun.

7. Would you rather want to have a werewolf as a friend or have a vampire as a friend?

Team Jacob or Team Edward? I personally would choose a vampire as my friend, even though there’s a risk they bite me and turn me into a vampire. However, immortality doesn’t sound too bad to me.

Top 5 Card Games for Adults
Suggested read: Top 5 Card Games for Adults

8. Would you rather sleep in a room full of spiders or sleep in a room full of snakes?

What are you more afraid of, snakes or spiders?

9. Would you rather only eat chocolate or only eat gummy candies for the rest of your life?

What’s your favorite chocolate or gummy candy?

10. Would you rather be able to transform into a bat or a black cat?

Which of them has the better life? If you chose to be a cat, would you like to be a street cat or a pet cat, and why?

11. Would you rather watch a scary movie or watch a funny movie?

How about a funny scary movie?

12. Would you rather play a prank on your siblings or play a prank on your parents?

Can you think of any prank you would play on your siblings or parents?

13. Would you rather eat a whole raw onion or eat a clove of garlic?

If you choose the clove of garlic, you no longer have to worry about vampires.

14. Would you rather walk through a dark forest on your own or walk through a dark graveyard on your own?

There’s definitely a higher chance of getting lost in the woods.

15. Would you rather be wrapped up like a mummy for one hour or lie in a closed coffin for one hour?

Both options are horrible for a claustrophobic person.

16. Would you rather have the ability to talk to ghosts or have the ability to turn invisible?

Imagine all the fun and spooky adventures you could have with either of these powers!

17. Would you rather have a pet black cat or a pet bat?

Which creature would make the perfect companion for your Halloween adventures?

If you’re looking for more fun non-Halloween-related questions, you should check out our massive Would You Rather Questions list. This list includes over 400 questions of different categories: 👉 Would You Rather - The Ultimate List of Questions

If you want to play Would You Rather online, you can do so here:

Play Online

App icon Would you rather?
Would you rather? Rated 4.9 stars out of five stars
🥳 Party 🤓 Quizzes 🕹 Games ✍️ Name Generators 👋 Conversation Starters 💭 Quotes 🍿 Videos 🎓 Trivia 👼 Angel Numbers 📱 Apps

Party & Drinking Games

Looking for some fun party games to liven up your next get-together? Check out our collection of 100+ party games for all ages!